GarryJolleyRogers - Wed Nov 25 2009 - Version 1.5
Parent topic: ImplementationsOfBDI.SDD
CIPRes is a major multi-institutional research initiative in phyloinformatics and computational phylogenetics. One of their staff, Main.ShirleyCohen, has begun evaluating SDD for its utility to various aspects of the CIPRes effort and has produced a rather interesting spreadsheet, attached, comparing SDD to current CIPRes representations. The spreadsheet is based, where it can be, on criteria elucidated by Mike Dallwitz comparing DELTA to NEXUS facilities.
Shirley's analysis was based on 0.91b16, but most things of interest to her haven't changed. I've spent a little time with her going over some of SDD 0.91b25; the attachment represents a few changes from her original. Herewith I make subtopics for the few issues in the spreadsheet where she couldn't see how to represent the concept in SDD. Some we clearly can do and I just ran out of time in our discussion. Some I don't see how to do, some I don't understand what's meant, and some we don't do (but maybe could easily). The major one we agreed(?) not to address in SDD 1.0 is character and state inheritance. Because a version of this spreadsheet is and may circulate on the cipres-dev list, I have added a local version number in case it evolves here
|row|feature |intent|sdd feature|sdd ver|spreadsheet ver| |23 |CharacterKeywords |unordered character sets|Concept Trees|0.91b25|1.0 23June2004| |44 |StructureOfTaxonNames|???|???|???|1.0 23June2004| |45 |
Note 1: Implicit values are difficult, since in DELTA they have two meanings: a) Default values to be inserted globally into the data matrix (this will not be supported, but replaced with data passed up/passed down features, implicit values are simply those passed down from the root). b) values inserted, but then removed from natural language output because they are considered implicit by the human reader (plants are generally green so the absence of green is reported, but protozoa generally not green, so presence of green is reported!) -- Gregor
For some comparison between DELTA and SDD, see Complexity of SDD versus DELTA and Exporting DELTA to SDD). Note that these documents refer to SDD 0.9, some of the outer structures have changed since. I will try to update the documents as soon as I have time. -- Gregor
-- Main.BobMorris / Gregor Hagedorn - 23 Jun 2004
Please someone add some semantics to